2003 Tertre-Rôteboeuf

"Since 1982 there have been two main kinds of vintages in Bordeaux," said Francois Mitjavile: "early, low-acid vintages that often show a heavy, animal character, and later vintages with fresh acidity and vibrant, more classic fruit flavors that some people would describe as lacking in maturity. But 2005 is the first vintage since 1982 that offers both total ripeness and freshness. There's a brilliance to the fruit in 2005. Some people have slightly underripe tannins that are well-buffered by fruit. But others have overextracted and gotten rude, hard tannins." Mitjavile noted that he did not harvest especially late in 2005, as he wanted to preserve freshness of fruit. "I only pick late in years when it's hard to ripen the fruit," he said.

According to Francois Mitjavile, 2003 was a terribly hot year during which the vineyards suffered. "The 2003 wines are extremely concentrated, black wines but also rude and aggressive, if not cooked," said Mitjavile. "The huge flowering in the late spring of 2004 then exhausted the vines. With the summer came an explosion of black and red septentrionale [northern in character] fruits. The problem is that it was nearly impossible to get the tannins thoroughly ripe, and the vintage has high acidity. Even here, our skins are not riper than those of 2002, but the fruit is explosive in 2004." Incidentally, Mitjavile's concept of terroir, of making a true estate wine, calls for growing the best possible fruit and then using it all: he has never made a second wine.

According to winemaker/philosopher Francois Mitjavile, "there is no general understanding of the 2003 vintage based on its faults and its qualities. The plant was completely disturbed during its vegetative cycle. Winemakers were also disturbed: some could have harvested too early or made the mistake of acidifying. And now early tasters are disturbed as well." Mitjavile maintains that there are three styles of wine on the Right Bank in 2003. "First, there are wines with cooked fruit and rustic tannins. But, where the plant could work until a late harvest, there are also wines with great corpulence and the kind of fresh, explosive red fruits we find in classic vintages. The third case is what we got here: a very original vintage, which does not mean something greater than the classic years. Here, 2003 brought extreme, complete maturity. We could expect Mediterranean aromas, but in fact we got Bordeaux aromas. The alcohol is very high but you don't taste it, in part because the tannins are so supple. The vintage is almost the opposite style from 2002: creamy tannins with caramelized flavors, while 2002 shows aggressive red fruits but is not as rich as 2003." Mitjavile compared the new wine to his '89, which he believes dried out slightly during its elevage "The 2003 is more evolved and more stable than the '89," he told me. More than ever before, I was struck by the extreme individuality of Le Tertre-Roteboeuf. In the ripest years, it's distinctly roasted and yet alive. "The idea of millesime is of disturbing strangeness," said Mitjavile. "It's by definition an extreme expression of appellation controlee To the end of crafting a wine that's an accurate expression of its harvest year, Mitjavile always assembles everything in the blend, including the press wine and vin de lie, during the fermentation process.