### New Releases from Washington State

The more I taste the better 2011 red wines from Washington State, the more excited I become about this vintage—and the more I wonder whether the warmest areas within the Columbia Valley’s high desert are just too hot in some years to make elegant, naturally balanced wines. Of course, the same statement can be made about any hot, dry region where the challenge is to get adequate ripeness of the grape skins before sugar levels skyrocket, grapes begin to dehydrate and natural acidity levels plunge.

Certainly, Washington’s growers and winemakers have gained an extraordinary amount of experience in recent years, as the last five growing seasons have presented an improbably wide range of temperature conditions:

2010: Cool

2011: Very cool (downright cold by Washington standards)

2012: Perfectly average, classic

2013: Very warm

2014: Seriously hot (record total degree days)

Thanks to the superb trio of vintages in 2010, 2011 and 2012, there are more outstanding Washington wines available in the retail marketplace, or on the way, than ever before. It gets better: there are also more excellent choices than ever in the $20 to $40 range. These bottlings are now beating the pants off most California wines at the same price for value and drinkability.

**A closer look at 2011.** As a vintage, 2011 is less consistent than 2010, as it was a freakishly cool year and grapes in some sites did not reach sufficient ripeness. Clearly, many wine lovers weaned on West Coast wines prefer more flesh and power in their red wines and are less accepting of cooler aromas and flavors than your Europhile correspondent is. But cleverly managed vineyards produced fruit in 2011 with excellent phenolic ripeness at lower-than-normal sugar levels. The successful wines from this vintage display fresh, perfumed aromas and complex, well-delineated flavors; fine-grained texture and noteworthy inner-mouth energy; and harmonious, smooth tannins. Wines from single sites also generally communicate their _terroir_ character far more clearly in 2011 than do wines from much riper years featuring a percentage of dehydrated grapes and considerably higher alcohol levels.

The 2011s also appear to have the natural acidity and overall balance to support graceful evolution in bottle. I have rarely found this combination of characteristics from past vintages in Washington. And it’s not just the elite producers who have excelled: in 2011, many wineries that have consistently made rather chunky red wines without much nuance or refinement have crafted much classier bottles.

Some growers reported a lighter-than-usual fruit set in 2011, while others said the flowering presaged a normal crop, but all agreed that work in the vineyards was necessary to get their fruit ripe in the abnormally cool conditions of 2011. “Yields had to be cut significantly to ensure proper ripening of the grapes,” said Billo Naravane of Rasa Vineyards. Naravane maintained that crop loads in cool years like 2010 and 2011 really must be kept to no more than two tons per acre to ensure optimal fruit quality.

According to Gilles Nicault, who directs winemaking for Long Shadows Vintners, “we were more aggressive right away in 2011 with thinning the crop and opening up the canopy early because we had benefited from our experience in 2010.” As in 2010, Washington enjoyed very good weather late in the growing season of 2011, and the added hang time (in the case of Long Shadows, well into November, said Nicault) allowed a moderate load of grapes to ripen slowly and brought greater concentration, color and complexity. And not only did Washington have the advantage of a long, leisurely maturation process but it did not have to deal with the often destructive harvest-time rains that plagued California’s North Coast.

Bob Betz, winemaker/patriarch at Betz Family Winery, told me that the temperature on September 1 of 2011 was higher than on June 1, July 1 and August 1. The end-of-season heat accumulation in 2011 salvaged the vintage, he added, and yielded wines with uncommon purity and expressiveness. And of course, normally very warm areas, such as the Red Mountain AVA in Yakima Valley, were at an advantage in the very cool 2011 growing season.

![](https://allgrapes.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads%2F1417552406810-Benches_vineyard+vinous.jpg)

_The Benches Vineyard in the Horse Heaven Hills AVA. Courtesy of Andréa Johnson Photography_

**The platonic growing season of 2012.** Two thousand twelve brought a return to more typical Washington warmth but, happily, it was a year without extremes. By most accounts, it was a perfectly average growing season with favorable harvest-time weather. And it is turning out to be a splendid year for white wines as well as reds. The successful wines of 2012—and there will likely be more of these than in any past vintage in Washington—show a charming balance of expressive, fresh aromas; fairly fleshy texture and noteworthy sweetness of fruit; and ripe tannins. The top reds, many of which I have not yet tasted in finished form, should give considerable early pleasure yet age well, although the more taut, wound-up 2011s may turn out to be the real long-distance runners. Time will tell.

“We enjoyed beautiful, even sunshine throughout the season,” said Naravane of 2012. “The fruit set was on the lighter side given the cooler climate in 2011, and not much thinning was required this year. The near-perfect growing conditions made vineyard management easy in 2012.” My early take on this vintage is that producers who did not succeed in ’12 should be in another line of work.

**An early look at 2013 (and 2014).** According to Betz, crop levels were potentially higher in both ’13 and ’14, “mostly due to 2012’s sun and warmth but also due to milder winters with little or no bud damage.” Unlike in 2011 and 2010, when Betz relentlessly dropped fruit to adjust for the cooler temperatures, in 2013 and especially 2014 he let a little more fruit hang “so that we could avoid harvesting big reds in August.” Still, he added, 2014 brought the earliest start to the harvest in 18 years, beginning on September 3.

“The heat in August of 2013 was oppressive,” noted Ben Smith of Cadence Winery, “but September cooled down enough to allow for a better balance of sugars and flavor development by the end of the ripening process. Two thousand fourteen was an even warmer year on Red Mountain in terms of total degree days, added Smith, but it was consistently hot while mostly avoiding the 100+-degree heat spikes of 2013.

“The major issue in 2013 and 2014 was how to cope with an abundance of sunshine,” said Naravane. “Sunburn was a major issue, particularly in August of both years. It was best to leave a higher leaf level on the western side of the vines to provide shade for the fruit. The fruit set was above average in both years, and both seasons allowed a slightly larger crop to ripen to perfection—assuming, of course, that steps were taken to delay ripening so that flavor development could occur before Brix levels skyrocketed.”

As is always the case in Washington, some growers no doubt jumped the gun in 2013 and 2014 and harvested before tannins were mature, as they were unnerved by high sugar levels in the grapes. And then there were those who had not booked picking crews and trucks sufficiently in advance and then, in the mad rush to harvest, were forced to wait much too long to bring in their grapes.

While I haven’t tasted more than a handful of 2013 reds yet, the white wines that I’ve tried do not generally possess the clarity or verve of the 2012s, not to mention the cooler 2011s and 2010s. I should note, however, that Gilles Nicault told me that this vintage brought white wines with good physiological maturity at reasonable sugar levels because mid-September was actually quite cool. And of course vineyards planted at higher altitude or in sites open to breezes off the Columbia River were generally more likely to excel in 2013 and 2014.

The following wines were tasted in Washington in July and in New York from late September through the beginning of November.

--Stephen Tanzer



New Releases from Washington State

New Releases from Washington State (Dec 2014)

ConstantScore(-article_id:{312 381 422 466 735 1092 1114 1146 1208 1209 1210 1231 1235 1241 1242 1245 1249 1258 1261 1276 1283 1298 1302 1312 1321 1325 1338 1601 1734 1980 1998 2164 2193 2198 2268 2425 2529 2566 2825 2994 3120 3140 3371 3977 4341} #producer.id:4343 #article_id:[504 TO 504])

DocValuesFieldExistsQuery [field=_primary_term]

Chateau Ste. Michelle

Content

Engage

Vinous

Social