2013 Napa Valley:
Once Upon a Time in America…
The bottled 2013 Napa
Valley Cabernet Sauvignons are every bit as viscerally thrilling as they have
always been in barrel. Inky, vibrant and structured, the wines possess remarkable
concentration, with bright acidity and powerful tannins to back it all up. Simply put, the 2013 Napa Cabernets are some of the most profound, riveting, young wines I have
tasted anywhere in the world.
2013 – A Modern-Day Classic
The second year in
the current drought cycle and precocious growing season produced powerful, inky
wines with huge fruit, massive tannins and, most importantly, extraordinary
pedigree. I expect the wines to evolve at a glacial pace. I first started following the 2013s in September of that year, a
period I usually set aside for visiting vineyards just before harvest. But in
2013, my timing was not so good, and I arrived right as the fruit was being
brought in. That provided a fascinating, early look at the vintage. By the time
I returned in October for my second fall trip I had a chance to taste a number
of wines straight from tank. The potential was evident. That early promise started to become a
reality when I returned in the spring of 2014 to
start tasting the wines from barrel for my article 2013 Napa Valley: A First Look…, which
has more context on the vintage and my early impressions on a number of wines.
the early morning fog, Spring Mountain, October 2015
were an issue from the outset in 2013. I remember speaking with growers in
January who were already concerned with the water deficit and were considering
irrigating imminently, which is unheard of at that time of year. Warm, drought
conditions led to one of the earliest harvests on record. Small berry sizes produced
wines with off-the-charts levels of concentration. In the cellar, the wines extracted
easily. So easily in fact that many winemakers were afraid of ending up with
monstrously tannic wines and purposely took their foot off the gas.
Multimedia: Explore the 2013 Napa Valley
Harvest Video Archive
Overall quality is
simply extraordinary. The rising tide has indeed lifted all boats, as can be
seen by the number of estates that over achieved and made brilliant wines. At
the top estates, where quality is consistently high, the pedigree of the
vintage manifests itself in second labels that are often better than flagship
wines at other properties. When all is said and done, there is little doubt
2013 will go down as one of the all-time great vintages for Napa Valley. Historically,
that lofty status in Napa Valley has been accorded to ripe vintages such as
1997, 2002 and 2007. But 2013 has little in common with those years. Two
thousand thirteen is much closer in style to 2001, a vintage that has only
started to drink well within the last few years. Although the weather
conditions were quite different, comparisons can also be made to 2010, except
the 2013s play on an entirely higher level. The 2013s are also far and away more
interesting and pedigreed than the 2012s, a vintage that was massively overhyped
largely because it was easy on growers after the very challenging 2011 and
slightly less difficult (but much higher in quality) 2010.
The quiet end of day, Forman, St.
Producers in Napa Valley
have the good fortune of working and living in one of the most privileged wine
producing regions anywhere in the world. For starters, the weather and overall
climatic conditions are extremely favorable for the cultivation of wine grapes
(and other crops). Shock events such as hail, frost and late season rain that
are common in other regions and countries are virtually unheard of.
Winemakers in Napa
Valley also have an extraordinary range of tools at their disposal. Irrigation
is virtually a necessity. That has given birth to a number of parallel fields of
specialization that hone in on very specific areas such as sap flow analysis
(which shows the rate at which water flows through a vine), or vineyard
development tools that provide the exact GPS coordinates to plant each single
vine (to ensure the desired exposure) and a host of other technical data. Most
wines are blends, which give wineries considerable flexibility in putting
together the final wines, a lever that is not available to producers in
Burgundy or Piedmont, to name two regions where the top wines are all
mono-varietals. Most Napa wines are aged in the standard 225-liter barrel.
Here, too, the smaller barrel size allows for maximum flexibility vis-à-vis
regions where larger casks such as those used in the Rhone, Montalcino and
Piedmont give producers much less of an ability to select the best micro-lots. Lastly,
owners with deep pockets can make economically irrational choices to only
bottle the very best of their production, something that most wineries simply
don’t have the luxury to do.
2014 – Hot On The Heels Of 2013
After the precocious 2013, no one expected another record breaking early harvest, but then 2014
arrived, and all bets were off. Budbreak was early by as much as six weeks. Perhaps
even more surprisingly, yields were high in 2014, then the third year of the
current drought cycle. I remember spending a week in Napa Valley in mid-April
and hearing producers explain that the vines were setting themselves up for an
abundant crop. And that is exactly what happened. The harvest also turned out
to be even earlier than 2013, but the season was quite
balanced. What little rain there was fell at the right time. Once again, my fall trips coincided with the
harvest, and I was able to get a first hand look at the action. In some cases,
estates had all of their Cabernet in by the end of September, which was unheard
of…at the time.
In the cellar, the
wines were slow to extract, so most producers kept the wines on the skins a bit
longer than normal. Despite the early start of the season and drought
conditions, the 2014s maintained gorgeous acidity, freshness and overall
energy.We shot quite a bit
of video that fall, all of which is available below.
Multimedia: Explore the 2014 Napa Valley Harvest
The 2014s are
distinctly mineral and savory, with less mid-palate intensity and depth than
the 2013s. I started tasting the 2014s this past spring, as is my custom. Since
then, the wines have only grown in stature and overall complexity. Quality at
the top estates is superb. A year ago, I thought 2014 would turn about to be a
sort of combination of 2012 and 2013, but the wines have now moved in a
direction that is far closer to 2013, albeit with less overt richness. My sense
is that 2014 will hold considerable appeal to readers with classically leaning
palates. The best wines are breathtakingly beautiful.
Archive: 2014 Napa Valley – Vintage Report
Looking Forward to 2015
– Start and Stop…Start and Stop
Two thousand fifteen
challenged growers from the beginning. The temperate, dry winter caused soils
to warm up early, which encouraged early budbreak and got things moving well
ahead of schedule, even by the standards that were set in 2013 and 2014.
Unseasonably cool weather in May wreaked havoc on flowering and lowered the
potential crop dramatically. Prolonged periods of heat followed for most of the
year, but maturity within the clusters themselves
was quite uneven. Sugars raced ahead while phenolic ripeness lagged. Some
producers picked early to preserve as much freshness as possible, while others
decided to wait it out and take advantage of the
gorgeous weather that started to set in during the early part of October, when
daytime highs remained elevated, but the effect of shorter days, and especially
cool nights, was evident.
Sunburn was an issue for most growers
The harvest was
interrupted at several points by brief spells of rain and rapidly changing
weather that caused vineyard managers to move pick dates around at the last minute. In
the end, producers reported yields that are down 30-50%. Most of that happened
in the spring. But ultimately, 2015 is a vintage that will have been made
through strict selection, either in the vineyard or at the sorting table, or
both. Given the wide quality of fruit I saw coming off the vine, I expect the wines
to be equally variable.
I did taste a few
early samples of the 2015s, and while I would expect winemakers to show only
their very best at this stage, I think it is fair to say there will be some
fabulous 2015s, although they are likely to be few and far between.
A typical grape bunch in 2015.
Note the widely varying levels of maturity and loose cluster architecture
the 2015 Harvest Video Archive
Napa Valley’s Identity Crisis
“I can’t drink more than a glass of any of
the wines I make for my consulting clients. These are the wines I actually want
to drink” – A top Napa Valley consulting
winemaker as he showed me the wines he makes under his own label.
There is something incredibly
fascinating happening in Napa Valley right now. Almost every winemaker I taste
with under the age of 40 or so has a deep fascination with the history of Napa
Valley, and the wines made during the 1960s and 1970s, the period most
observers would say was the first Golden Age of Napa Valley wines.
And yet, the pull of the market
remains so incredibly strong in the opposite direction. One of the main topics
of discussion during my three weeks of estate visits this fall was the Wagner
family’s sale of their Pinot Noir brand, Meomi, for $315 million. Good for
them. Entrepreneurship is at the very heart of the American Dream. And if these
are the wines that ultimately lead beer and spirits drinkers into wine, so much
But most of Napa Valley’s estates
aspire to a higher level of quality. And the simple fact is that many young winemakers
are not making the wines they really want to make, they are making wines for
someone else; whether that is an estate owner or a broader concept of what the
market wants. Today’s consumer, though, is far more travelled and cultured than
the consumer from a generation ago. The awareness of food alone in this country
has literally exploded over the last few decades, but wine lags. I do not believe
the consumer wants things dumbed down. Not surprisingly, over the last few
years, I have seen a marked, but sometimes subtle, stylistic shift towards the
center as winemakers are increasingly comfortable with their own convictions.
Things I Liked This Year
2013 & 2014 – Two superb vintages for Napa Valley
The total package – Napa Valley’s combination of world-class
wines, stunning natural beauty, great weather and fabulous food culture can only
be equaled by a few places in the world that I know of. Piedmont is one, in
case you are wondering.
Turnarounds – Inglenook, Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars and
Clos du Val all appear to be moving in the right direction. It will be
interesting to see what effect a recent winemaker change at Clos du Val brings,
but the last two vintages have been terrific.
New projects – It’s always interesting to see new
projects get off the ground. I have been fortunate to see quite a few wineries
emerge in recent years, but the pipeline for the future is also looking bright.
Promontory – The wines from Bill
Harlan’s rugged, hillside property continue to improve in a meaningful way.
Helen Keplinger – Keplinger’s first vintages at Grace,
Blank and Carte Blanche are all impressive, while her own wines (reviewed in
our Sonoma issue) are the best I have tasted so far.
Turley – Larry Turley and winemaker Tegan Passalacqua make a wide range
of absolutely gorgeous old-vine wines that celebrate California’s heritage
sites and that deliver superb quality for the money.
The Vineyardist – Proprietors Dirk Fulton and Becky Kukkola
continue to invest in their pristine Diamond Hill estate. The small, onsite
winery is not fully finished, but it is now operational.
Keeping it real – Producers for whom delivering value is
Lorenz Peterson’s original Victorian home,
The Vineyardist, Diamond Mountain
Things I Didn’t Like This Year
Over-Decanting – Two
hours of air is good, so twelve is better, right? No. Young wines can respond negatively to too much air by shutting down hard.
First-Come, First-Served Mailing Lists – This
abhorrent, anti-consumer business practice can and does result in long-time,
repeat customers getting shut out of highly desirable wines. Note to wineries:
the people who can afford to buy your wines have busy lives and more to do in a
day than sit by their computers/phones waiting for an offer to arrive.
Guaranteed allocations that need to be purchased within a limited time frame is
a much more pro-consumer model. And of course, this critique is not Napa Valley
specific, but applies to all wineries in the US that sell direct to the consumer.
Maybe bigger isn’t better – I
was deeply disappointed to learn that the magnums I bought of an expensive,
highly regarded Cabernet Sauvignon were bottled semi-manually and not on a fully
automated bottling line, which introduces the slight possibility of human error
and bottle variation. I’m pretty speechless about this one. Actually, I’m not.
The technology to bottle magnums on a line has been around for 25 years or so.
So much for using mobile bottlers in order to have access to the most modern
I strongly encourage Vinous
readers to inquire about how large formats (magnums or larger) are bottled
before buying those wines. To be fair, this is an issue in every region, but in
Napa Valley, where prices are often in the stratosphere, there is simply no
reason for a product to be flawed when the root cause is so easily identifiable
First-Off & Last-Off Bottles – I suspect most consumers have never heard
of this term. I had never heard of it until a few years ago. To ensure
calibration and consistency during the bottling process, it is quite common for
the first and last case (approximately) of freshly bottled wine to be separated
from the rest of the run. These ‘first off’ and ‘last off’ bottles rarely see
the light of day, because they are often not representative of the finished,
commercially available wine. Some producers, though, use these bottles for
samples in their tasting room. The ‘last off’ bottles are especially troubling
because they contain more deposits and are often excessively heavy and/or
oxidized. I was shocked to learn wineries put their labels on these very
bottles and serve them to their visitors. If a winery pours you one of these bottles,
this is what they are saying to you:
1) We are
serving you the dregs from the bottom of our tanks because we don’t think you
can tell the difference
2) Even though
you have travelled from afar to be here and visit our winery (and probably paid
for this tasting), we don’t value your time
Of course, first off and last off
bottles are an issue in other regions as well, but it is especially egregious
in Napa Valley, where the bottle price is so high.
Missing in Action
As always, there are a few
estates I missed, usually because of a combination of scheduling, the recent
bottling of wines, and other logistical/practical issues. There are also a
handful of wineries that choose not to show their wines, including Maybach,
Peter Michael, Schrader, and, for the first time, Araujo Estate. Because this
article is being published earlier than has been the norm over the last few
years, wines from these producers are not yet available, but once they are in
the market I will buy them, taste them and add reviews to our database.
Tasting the 2015s block by block at Vine Hill
Readers should expect to see a
supplement to this article towards the end of the year. This article alone
contains well over 1,000 reviews but as always, there are late arriving samples
and other wines as described above that merit coverage that I was not able to
taste this fall.
You Might Also Enjoy
Uncovering the Best Values in California Cabernet Sauvignon, Antonio Galloni, October 2015
2014 Napa Valley – Vintage Report, Antonio Galloni, June 2015
New Releases from Napa Valley: 2012 and 2013, Antonio Galloni, December 20142013 Napa Valley: A First Look…
, Antonio Galloni, May 2014
The Undiscovered California – 2015 Edition, Antonio Galloni, January 2015
This article is dedicated to the memory of my
dear friend Nick Simmons; brilliant musician, painter, husband and father.
-- Antonio Galloni